Mini Minds Hub · Free printable

Mud Pie Drying Test: Free Printable Worksheet for Year 4

  • ForYear 4
  • StageKey Stage 2
  • CostFree
  • FormatPrintable PDF

Mud Pie Drying Test asks Year 4 children (ages 8 to 9) to read a results table from Mia's investigation, rank three equal mud pies by how fast they dried, then answer questions about fair testing and evaporation. It suits children who are learning about states of matter or practising how to plan a fair test.

Start by modelling the ranking. Point to the column headed Rank (1 = fastest) and ask which column tells you how fast a pie dried. The usual slip is ranking by temperature instead of minutes. Ask your child to check each rank by saying, 'This pie took fewer minutes than that one, so...'.

What is on the sheet

Children fill in a results table with four columns: Place, Temperature, Minutes to dry and Rank (1 = fastest). Then they answer numbered questions with space to write. The questions ask them to spot what Mia changes, name something she keeps the same, find how many minutes longer one pie took, and explain where the water goes. They also predict for a new place, explain how warmth affects evaporation and judge why Sam's change is unfair.

  • Place
  • Temperature
  • Minutes to dry
  • Rank (1 = fastest)
  • Which one thing does Mia change in her test?
  • Write one thing Mia must keep the same.
  • How many minutes longer did the shed pie take than the patio pie?
  • Where does the water go as a mud pie dries?
  • Predict: a windowsill at 28°C. Faster or slower than the patio? Why?
  • Explain how warmth speeds up evaporation.
  • Sam makes the shed pie bigger. Why is this unfair?

Try it in the garden

Make equal pies

Mix soil and water to the same thickness. Use the same cup or pot to shape each pie so they start equal. Put each one on its own plate or tile.

Choose the places

Pick three spots around the garden or yard. Look for sunny, shady and sheltered places. Write the names of the spots in a table like the one on the sheet.

Check and record

Look at each pie at regular times and write down what you see. Decide as a group what counts as dry before you begin, so every pie is judged the same way.

Why mud pies make a good science test

Mud is simply soil mixed with water. Most children have made mud pies, so the starting point is familiar. In Year 4, children learn that materials can be solids, liquids or gases, and that water can move between these states. A drying mud pie is a safe, everyday way to see water change state without special equipment.

Mia's test is also a lesson in working scientifically. To compare things fairly, a scientist changes one thing, measures what happens and keeps everything else the same. Then the results can be trusted. A table helps because it puts the numbers side by side, so patterns are easier to see and explain.

If you try the garden version, wash hands well after handling mud and soil, and cover any cuts first. Keep mud away from faces and mouths. Wear old clothes and play outdoors.

Quick facts about drying

  • Mud is made of soil and water.
  • Water can be a solid, a liquid or a gas. These are called states of matter.
  • Wet washing on a line dries without anyone wringing it out.
  • Puddles can shrink and disappear after the rain stops.
  • Scientists often repeat a test to check their results can be trusted.

Skills and curriculum link

  • Fair testing
  • Reading a results table
  • Ranking from data
  • Comparing numbers
  • Predicting with a reason
  • Explaining evaporation

Ideas to help your child think it through

  • Read the table by columnRun a finger down one column at a time. Ask what each heading is measuring and what unit it uses. This makes the table less crowded.
  • RankingA rank is a position in order. Rank 1 is the first place, so check the key on the sheet to see what first place means here.
  • Fair test thinkingIn a fair test, only one thing is different between the tests. Ask your child what is different and what is the same in each one.
  • Using 'because'A good science answer gives a reason. Encourage 'I think... because...' so the answer says what happens and why.

Key words

  • EvaporationA change of state. A liquid slowly becomes a gas.
  • Fair testA test where only one thing is changed and the other things stay the same.
  • VariableSomething in a test that can change.
  • PredictSay what you think will happen before you test it, and give a reason.
  • RankPut things in order, for example from first to last.
  • State of matterThe form a material takes, such as solid, liquid or gas.

How to use it

  1. Print both pages. Page 1 is for your child. Keep page 2, which has the notes and answers.
  2. Look at the table together. Point to each column heading and say what it means.
  3. Ask your child to fill in the Rank column first, using the key on the sheet.
  4. Let them answer the questions in order. Ask them to say their reasons aloud before they write.
  5. Check with page 2 together. Ask, 'How did you decide?' Come back another day to try the harder questions again.

Help, stretch and game ideas

If it feels too hard

Read the table together and point to each column. Cover everything except one row at a time. Give sentence starters such as 'It is warmer, so the water...'. Do the ranking first, then tackle the questions one at a time with a break between.

To stretch confident children

Plan a second test with a new variable, such as wind. Say what you would change, what you would keep the same and what you would measure. Draw a blank results table for it and write a prediction with a reason.

Make it a game

In the garden, make equal pies and place them in different spots. Check them every ten minutes. Before each check, children predict which pie is driest. Score a point for each correct prediction and talk about why.

Mistakes to watch for

Watch forA child ranks the pies by temperature instead of by minutes to dry.

Try thisReturn to the key. Ask, 'What does 1 = fastest mean?' Then point to the column that shows how long each pie took.

Watch forA child adds the minutes together or subtracts the wrong way round when finding the difference.

Try thisDraw a number line. Mark the two times and count or jump the gap between them. Ask, 'Which is the longer time?'

Watch forA child answers with 'because it is hot' and nothing more.

Try thisAsk what happens to the water. Offer a sentence starter, then ask them to add a second sentence that links the cause to the result.

Talk about it

  • What do you think Mia was trying to find out?
  • Why is it important to change only one thing?
  • What would you look for to decide a pie is dry?
  • Where else have you seen something dry out outdoors?
  • If you ran this test again, would you expect the same results? Why?
  • What could Mia change next to learn something new?

Take it off the page

Washing line test

Hang two damp cloths in different places at home. Make sure they start equally wet. Check them and talk about which one seems drier and why.

Puddle watch

After rain, draw round the edge of a puddle with chalk. Come back later and look again. Talk about what has happened to the water.

Design a results table

Think of another thing that dries, such as a paper towel or a sponge. Draw a table with columns for the place, what you measure and the rank. Plan your test before you try it.

Who it is for

Parents

Sit with your child for the first read, then let them lead. Ask for reasons as well as answers. If they get stuck, go back to the table and read one row aloud. A real mud pie afternoon makes a good follow up.

Teachers

Use it as a starter or plenary in a states of matter unit, or as a recap of fair testing. It works for early finishers, supply cover or homework. Page 2 gives support and stretch ideas for mixed groups.

Home educators

This fits easily into a wider science plan with outdoor play and everyday talk. Pair it with the garden version so children see the idea for themselves. The sheet can be printed again for brothers, sisters or revision later.

Where this fits in science

Before this, children observe, compare and sort materials, and ask simple questions about what they notice. They also meet the idea that water can be a liquid and a solid. Those early habits help them read a table and describe what they see.

After this, children in Year 5 study the properties and changes of materials, including dissolving and separating mixtures. They also plan their own fair tests more independently, choosing which variables to change, measure and control.

Questions parents and teachers ask

What age is Mud Pie Drying Test for?

It is written for Year 4 (ages 8 to 9), in Key Stage 2. Children who are slightly younger or older can still use it with adult support or as a stretch, depending on how confident they are with tables and science vocabulary.

What will children practise?

Children practise planning and judging a fair test, reading a results table and explaining evaporation. The topic is states of matter. They also rank results, find a difference between two numbers and make a prediction with a reason.

Do children need to make real mud pies?

No. The sheet works on paper alone, using the results given. A garden mud pie test is a good extra if you have time and outdoor space, but it is not needed to complete the sheet.

What if the sheet feels too hard?

Read the table together and point to each column. Cover all but one row at a time. Offer sentence starters such as 'It is warmer, so the water...'. Do the ranking first, then answer the questions in short bursts.

Does the sheet include answers?

Yes. Page 2 is for the adult and includes the answers, notes on how to use the sheet, help for children who find it hard and a stretch idea. Keep it separate until your child has finished.

Is it suitable for teachers to use in class?

Yes. Teachers can use it as a starter, plenary, early finisher task, homework or table activity. It needs no preparation beyond printing. Page 2 supports mixed ability groups with help and stretch ideas.

Is it a screen free activity, and do I need colour?

Yes to the first, no to the second. It needs only paper and a pencil, and it prints well in black and white on plain A4 paper. That makes it handy for quiet time, rainy days and holidays.

Preview the full PDF

Made by Jaques of London, making games for families since 1795. A printable supports classroom learning and does not replace a teacher.