Mini Minds Hub · Free printable
Stamp of Approval: Free Printable Worksheet for Year 9
- ForYear 9
- StageKey Stage 3
- CostFree
- FormatPrintable PDF
Stamp of Approval asks Year 9 pupils (ages 13 to 14) to read a client brief for a stamp, write ranked specification points, sketch two ideas and score each idea against those points. It suits design and technology at Key Stage 3, and page 2 gives the grown up notes, help ideas, a stretch task and the answers.
Before pupils start, model turning one vague wish into a testable point. Take "looks good" and rewrite it so someone else could check it by counting, measuring or answering yes or no. The usual slip is writing opinions, so ask "How would a classmate test that?" about every point.
What is on the sheet
Pupils begin by reading the client brief and answering the numbered questions, which include naming two groups of people who will see or use the stamp. Next they fill in a table of specification points and rank them. Then they sketch Idea A and Idea B, labelling two features on each. Finally they score both ideas from 0 to 2 against their own points and compare the results.
- Name two groups of people who will see or use the stamp.
- Rank
- Your specification point
- Idea A (0 to 2)
- Idea B (0 to 2)
- Idea A: sketch and label two features
- Idea B: sketch and label two features
Building a strong specification
Read the brief twice
The first read gives the general picture. On the second read, underline anything the client asks for or any limit they set. Each underline can become a specification point.
Make every point testable
A point is testable if another person could check it without guessing. Use a number, a count, a measurement or a clear yes or no question.
Rank before you sketch
Decide which points matter most, then put them in order in the table. If two points pull against each other, the ranking tells you which one wins.
Score with evidence
When you score an idea, point to the labelled feature on the sketch that earns the mark. A score with no feature to back it up is only a guess.
Why designers write a specification
A design brief is a short description from a client that says what they need. It does not say what the finished design looks like. The designer turns the brief into a specification, which is a list of points the design must meet. Good points are specific. They can be checked by measuring, counting or asking a clear yes or no question. Ranking them shows which points matter most when a design cannot do everything.
Writing the specification before sketching keeps the designer honest. If the points come after the drawing, it is easy to write points the drawing already meets. Scoring two ideas against the same list makes the comparison fair. Designers often find that neither idea is perfect, and the scores show which features to keep, change or combine in the next version.
Skills and curriculum link
- Reading a client brief
- Writing testable specification points
- Ranking priorities
- Sketching and labelling ideas
- Judging designs against criteria
Ideas that help with this sheet
- ClientThe client is the person or group who asks for the design. Their needs come first, so reading the brief closely is the first job.
- SpecificationA specification is a list of what a design must do or be. It is written before ideas are drawn, so it can be used to judge them.
- TestableA testable point can be checked in a clear way. Numbers, counts and yes or no questions make points easier to test than opinions.
- CriteriaCriteria are the standards used to judge something. Here, the specification points are the criteria for scoring each sketch.
Key words
- BriefA short description of what a client wants designed.
- ClientThe person or group who asks for the design.
- SpecificationA list of points that a design must meet.
- TestableAble to be checked in a clear way, such as by counting or measuring.
- CriteriaThe standards used to judge how good a design is.
- AnnotateAdd short labels to a sketch to explain its features.
How to use it
- Print both pages. Page 1 is for the pupil. Keep page 2, which has the notes and answers.
- Read the client brief together and underline what the client needs. Then let the pupil answer questions 1 to 4 in their own words.
- Write the specification points in the table and rank them before any sketching. Check that each point could be tested by someone else.
- Sketch Idea A and Idea B, labelling two features on each. Then score each idea from 0 to 2 against every point.
- Check against page 2 and talk through the scores. Ask which idea won and which point should change next time.
Help, stretch and game ideas
If it feels too hard
Give sentence starters such as "The stamp must be..." and share one model testable point, for example uses no more than four colours. Ask the pupil to write just two points first, rank them, then add more once they feel sure.
To stretch confident children
Ask the pupil to pick their lowest ranked point and rewrite it so it can be measured. Then they explain in a few sentences how a classmate could test it, and what result would count as a full score.
Make it a game
Pin the sketches up as a gallery. Classmates score each idea using the designer's specification, then compare their scores with the designer's own. Talk about any big differences and what they say about how clear each point is.
Mistakes to watch for
Watch forPoints are opinions, such as "looks nice", so they cannot be scored fairly.
Try thisAsk how someone else could check the point. Add a number, a count or a yes or no question so the score does not depend on taste.
Watch forThe specification is written after the sketches, so the points simply describe the drawings.
Try thisCover the sketching boxes until the table is complete. Write and rank the points first, then draw.
Watch forBoth ideas receive the same score with no reason given.
Try thisAsk the pupil to point to the labelled feature that earns each mark. If there is no feature to point to, the score should go down.
Talk about it
- Who is the client, and what do they care about most?
- Which of your points could you test in under a minute?
- Why did you rank your top point above the others?
- Which feature on Idea A would you like to borrow for Idea B?
- What would you change in your specification if you did this again?
- How did you decide between a score of 1 and a score of 2?
Take it off the page
Stamp spotting
If you have letters or stamps at home, look closely at them. Talk about size, colour and amount of detail, and which parts you notice first.
Spec for a school bag
Write three testable points for a school bag, such as a size limit or a number of pockets. Rank them and swap with someone to see if they agree.
Compare two everyday objects
Pick two mugs or two pens. Choose three criteria, score each object from 0 to 2 and see which wins. Then ask whether the winner changes if you rank the criteria differently.
Who it is for
Parents
Read the brief aloud and let your child lead. Ask them to explain each specification point in their own words. You do not need design knowledge, only curiosity about why they ranked and scored as they did.
Teachers
Use it as a starter before a design task, a plenary on evaluating, a homework task or a cover lesson. Insisting on the specification before sketching makes the criteria clear and gives an easy way to check understanding.
Home educators
Pair it with real objects around the house. Ask the learner to write a short specification for something they use every day, then score two versions of it. The sheet works for revision or for a younger sibling to watch and discuss.
Where this skill fits
Before this sheet, pupils will usually have met simple design briefs and drawn labelled sketches. They may have judged finished products by saying what they like, without clear criteria. This sheet moves them towards points that can be checked and compared.
After it, pupils can use a specification to develop one chosen idea, build a model or prototype and evaluate it against the same points. At Key Stage 4 they write fuller specifications and use them to justify design decisions.
Questions parents and teachers ask
- What age is Stamp of Approval for?
It is written for Year 9 (ages 13 to 14), in Key Stage 3. It also works for confident Year 8 pupils, or for older pupils who need practice writing specifications and judging designs against them.
- What will children practise?
Children practise reading a client brief, writing ranked and testable specification points, and judging two design ideas against them. It is a short, focused task in design and technology rather than a full project.
- How do I use it?
Pupils work down page 1 in order. They answer the questions, write and rank the specification, then sketch two ideas and score them. Writing the specification before sketching means the ideas are judged against the points, not the other way round.
- What if it feels too hard?
Offer sentence starters such as "The stamp must be..." and a model testable point, for example uses no more than four colours. Ask for two points first, then build up. Working through the first go together also helps.
- Is it free?
Yes. It is free to print for home and classroom use. You can print it again for other pupils or for revision, and black and white printing works well on plain A4 paper.
- Can teachers use it in class?
Yes. Teachers can use it as a starter, plenary, early finisher task, homework or table activity. It needs no preparation beyond printing, and page 2 has support and stretch ideas for mixed ability groups.
- How long does it take?
It depends on how much detail pupils put into their sketches and scoring. There is no set time, so let them work at their own pace. It can be split across two sittings, with the specification in the first.
Preview the full PDF
Made by Jaques of London, making games for families since 1795. A printable supports classroom learning and does not replace a teacher.