Mini Minds Hub · Free printable

Friendship Badge Designer: Free Printable Worksheet for Year 5

  • ForYear 5
  • StageKey Stage 2
  • CostFree
  • FormatPrintable PDF

Friendship Badge Designer asks Year 5 children (ages 9 to 10) to write three design rules for a badge, sketch two different badge ideas, then score each idea against the rules to choose a winner. It suits children who enjoy drawing and making choices, and it gives quieter thinkers a clear way to explain why one design works better than another.

Before your child starts, model one rule together. Compare "The badge must be nice" with "The badge must be easy to see from across a room". Ask, "Could I score a badge 0, 1 or 2 against this rule?" If the answer is not clear, the rule needs sharpening. The usual slip is a vague rule that every sketch passes.

What is on the sheet

Children begin with a table of three rules. Rule 1 is about who the badge is for, rule 2 is about how it looks and rule 3 is about how it is made or worn. Each rule starts with the words "The badge must", and children finish the sentence. Next they sketch and label Idea A and Idea B in two boxes. Last, they score each idea against each rule, giving 0, 1 or 2, and use the scores to choose.

  • Rule 1 (who it is for): The badge must be...
  • Rule 2 (how it looks): The badge must show...
  • Rule 3 (how it is made or worn): The badge must be...
  • Idea A: sketch and label
  • Idea B: sketch and label
  • My rule
  • Idea A (0, 1 or 2)
  • Idea B (0, 1 or 2)

How the sheet builds a design

Rules come first

Children write their rules before they draw anything. This means the rules guide the sketches, rather than the sketches being explained afterwards.

Two ideas, not one

Sketching Idea A and Idea B gives children something to compare. Labels let them point out the features that matter, such as size, shapes or how the badge is worn.

Honest scoring

Each idea earns 0, 1 or 2 against each rule. A 0 means the rule is not met, and a 2 means it is met well. Honest scores are more useful than high ones.

Choosing and explaining

The scores help children pick a favourite. Ask them to say which rule decided it. That is the evaluating part of design and technology.

Why write rules before designing?

Designers usually start with a brief and a list of requirements, often called design criteria. These are statements that a product must meet. Writing them first stops a designer drifting towards whatever is most fun to draw. It also gives a fair way to compare ideas later, because every idea is held up against the same list.

A badge is a good product for practising this. It is small, so a child can sketch it in minutes. It has a clear user, the person who wears it. It also has limits that matter, such as size, how easy it is to read and how it stays on clothing. Those limits turn "I like it" into reasons a child can explain.

Skills and curriculum link

  • Writing design criteria
  • Sketching ideas
  • Labelling a drawing
  • Evaluating against criteria
  • Making a reasoned choice
  • Thinking about the user

Ideas to share with your child

  • Good rules can be testedA useful rule is one you can check. "Easy to see" can be judged by holding the sketch at arm's length. "Nice" is harder to judge.
  • Labels add informationA drawing shows what something looks like. Labels explain materials, sizes and why a feature is there.
  • Scores are evidenceA score is a way of showing how well an idea meets a rule. It is not the same as how much you like your own drawing.
  • Designs can improveDesigners rarely stop at the first idea. Scoring shows which rule is weakest, and that tells you what to change next.

Key words

  • Design criteriaRules a design must follow to do its job well.
  • SketchA quick drawing that shows an idea. It does not need to be neat.
  • LabelA short note with a line pointing to part of a drawing.
  • EvaluateLook carefully at something and decide how well it works.
  • UserThe person who will wear, use or look at the product.
  • ScoreA number that shows how well an idea meets a rule.

How to use it

  1. Print both pages. Page 1 is for your child. Keep page 2, which has notes, help ideas, a stretch idea and the answers.
  2. Read the three rule starters together. Talk about who the badge is for before anyone writes.
  3. Ask your child to finish all three rules before sketching. Then they sketch and label Idea A and Idea B.
  4. Share the ideas aloud. Then let your child score each badge against each rule, giving 0, 1 or 2, as honestly as they can.
  5. Check page 2 together. Ask which rule helped most in choosing, and come back another day to redesign a badge.

Help, stretch and game ideas

If it feels too hard

Offer sentence starters for rules, such as small enough, easy to see or simple to make. Score one rule together first, saying out loud why Idea A earns 0, 1 or 2. Then let your child score the remaining rules on their own.

To stretch confident children

Redesign the lower scoring badge to fix its weakest rule. Rescore it against the same rules and explain what improved. Then ask whether the new version beats the first winner, and why.

Make it a game

Swap sheets with a partner. They score your badges against your rules, without any help from you. Then compare totals. Talk about any rule where the scores differ. Was the rule clear enough, or does it need rewording?

Mistakes to watch for

Watch forThe rules are too vague, such as "The badge must look good", so both badges score the same.

Try thisAsk, "How could someone check this?" Rewrite the rule so it can be tested, such as "The badge must use no more than two colours".

Watch forThe child sketches first and writes the rules to match the drawing.

Try thisCover the sketch boxes until the rules are done. Explain that the rules are there to guide the drawings.

Watch forEvery idea scores 2 for every rule.

Try thisAsk for evidence. Hold each sketch up against the rule and ask, "Where can I see that?" Look for one rule that could be better.

Talk about it

  • Who would wear your badge, and why would they want to?
  • Which rule was hardest to write? What made it tricky?
  • How is Idea A different from Idea B?
  • Which score did you find hardest to give? Why?
  • If you could change one thing about your winning badge, what would it be?
  • Would your rules work for a different kind of badge? What would you change?

Take it off the page

Make a card badge

Choose the winning design and copy it onto stiff card. Colour it with pencils or pens. An adult should deal with any pins or cutting that needs care, and a string loop works instead of a pin.

Badge for a family member

Ask someone at home what they would like a badge to show. Write three rules from what they say. Sketch one design and see if they agree it fits.

Spot the badges

Look for badges, logos or signs on clothes and around your home or street. Choose one and say what rules its designer may have followed.

Who it is for

Parents

Sit beside your child for the first rules, then let them lead. Ask questions rather than giving answers. Praise clear thinking and honest scoring, not only neat drawing. Keep page 2 to hand for help ideas.

Teachers

Use it as a starter before a making project, as a plenary after teaching design criteria, or as a table task. Pair work suits the swap and score game. Page 2 gives support and stretch ideas for mixed ability groups.

Home educators

Pair it with a making session. Children can write rules, choose a design and then build it from card, paper or scraps. Repeat with another product, such as a bookmark or a bag tag, to practise the same skill.

Where this skill fits

Before this, children often design by drawing something they like and describing it. Earlier work in design and technology usually involves talking about who a product is for and what it needs to do. This sheet takes that a step further by asking children to write those needs down as rules.

After this, children can use design criteria to plan a real product, then make it and test it against the same rules. They can also compare a finished product with their original criteria, and explain what worked and what they would change.

Questions parents and teachers ask

What age is Friendship Badge Designer for?

It is written for Year 5 (ages 9 to 10), in Key Stage 2. It can also suit nearby year groups, depending on how confident a child is with writing rules and explaining choices.

What will children practise?

Children practise writing design criteria and judging their own designs against those criteria. They also sketch and label ideas. These link to the design and evaluate strands of design and technology at Key Stage 2.

How do I use it?

Children write their three rules first, then sketch two badge ideas. Share the ideas aloud, then let your child score each badge honestly against each rule. Use page 2 to check and to find help and stretch ideas.

What if it feels too hard?

Give sentence starters for rules, such as small enough, easy to see or simple to make. Score one rule together first, saying your reasons aloud. Then let your child score the rest on their own.

Does my child need to be good at drawing?

No. The sketches only need to show the idea, and labels can explain the rest. The learning is in writing clear rules and judging the designs against them, not in neat artwork.

Is it suitable for teachers to use in class?

Yes. It works as a starter, plenary, early finisher task, homework or table activity. It needs no preparation beyond printing. Partner scoring is a good way to get children talking about their criteria.

Do I need to print in colour?

No. It prints well in black and white on plain A4 paper. Children only need a pencil, though coloured pencils can be fun if they want to colour the winning badge afterwards.

Preview the full PDF

Made by Jaques of London, making games for families since 1795. A printable supports classroom learning and does not replace a teacher.