Mini Minds Hub · Free printable
Case of the Missing Minus: Free Printable Worksheet for Year 8
- ForYear 8
- StageKey Stage 3
- CostFree
- FormatPrintable PDF
Case of the Missing Minus is a maths worksheet for Year 8 (ages 12 to 13). Children solve six calculations with negative numbers, decimals and fractions, then check the filed answers and catch the one that has lost its minus sign.
Before anyone calculates, model one habit: say whether the answer should land above or below zero. Children then compare their final line with that estimate. The usual slip is a right method followed by a dropped sign at the very end, and this check catches it.
What is on the sheet
Children work through numbered calculations with space to answer and lines for writing. The questions mix negative integers, decimals and fractions, and the last one asks for the answer as a mixed number. Once the evidence is solved, children look at the filed answers, decide which one is wrong, and write a short explanation of the sign error. The task rewards method and reasoning, not just quick answers.
- Negative 8 + 5 =
- 4 subtract negative 6 =
- Negative 3.5 + 1.25 =
- 0.6 subtract 1.5 =
- 1/2 subtract 3/4 =
- Negative 3/4 divided by negative 1/2 (give a mixed number) =
Worked example: subtracting a negative
9 subtract negative 7 =
This question is not on the sheet. It shows two ways to think about subtracting a negative number.
Method 1: use a number line- Mark 9 on a number line.
- Subtracting a negative number moves you to the right, not the left.
- Jump 7 places to the right from 9. You land on 16.
- Subtracting a negative number gives the same result as adding the matching positive number.
- Rewrite 9 subtract negative 7 as 9 + 7.
- Add: 9 + 7 = 16.
Building the skill before the sheet
Start with a number line
Draw a line with zero in the middle. Ask children to place numbers on both sides and say which is larger. Many sign errors begin with a weak picture of where negative numbers sit.
Say the operation in words
Read each calculation aloud in full, such as "start at, then take away a negative". Hearing the words helps children see that two signs side by side do different jobs.
Match the denominators first
For fraction questions, write both fractions with the same denominator before doing anything else. Then add or subtract the numerators and keep the denominator.
Estimate, calculate, compare
Predict the sign and rough size of the answer. Work it out. Then check the result against the prediction before moving on.
Why signs go missing
A minus sign is a very small mark, but it changes the meaning of a whole answer. Negative numbers appear in everyday life, for example in temperatures below freezing or in money that is owed. A number with the wrong sign describes a completely different situation, so checking the sign matters as much as checking the digits.
Sign errors usually happen at one of two points. Some children lose the sign while copying a line of working. Others apply a rule they half remember. Fractions and decimals add more steps, which gives more places to slip. Writing each line neatly, and checking the sign at the end, builds a habit that carries into later algebra.
Skills and curriculum link
- Negative number calculations
- Fraction arithmetic
- Decimal arithmetic
- Estimating the sign
- Spotting errors
- Explaining reasoning
Ideas that help with the evidence
- Zero is a landmarkZero separates positive numbers from negative numbers. Ask whether a calculation starts on one side of zero and moves towards it, away from it, or across it.
- Common denominatorsFractions can only be added or subtracted when the pieces are the same size. Rewrite them with a shared denominator first.
- Estimate firstBefore working out an answer, decide roughly how big it should be and whether it should be above or below zero. Then compare.
- Show every lineWrite one step per line and carry the sign down each time. Most lost minus signs disappear while copying.
Key words
- Negative numberA number less than zero, written with a minus sign in front.
- SubtractTake away, or find how far one number is from another.
- DecimalA number with a decimal point, such as 2.5, showing parts of a whole.
- Common denominatorA shared bottom number that lets you compare, add or subtract fractions.
- Mixed numberA whole number and a fraction together, such as 2 and 1/3.
- Filed answerAn answer already written down in the record. Your job is to check it.
How to use it
- Print both pages. Page 1 is for the child. Keep page 2, which has the notes and answers.
- Read the task together. Explain that each filed answer might be right or wrong, and the child's job is to prove which.
- Ask the child to say whether each answer should be above or below zero before they calculate.
- Let them work on page 1, writing each step on its own line. Then they judge the filed answers and write their explanation.
- Check with page 2 and ask, "How do you know?" Come back another day to redo any tricky ones.
Help, stretch and game ideas
If it feels too hard
Offer a number line for the integer and decimal questions, and let children mark their start point and jumps. For fractions, rewrite both with a common denominator before any calculating. Try the first few questions together, then let them continue alone.
To stretch confident children
Ask children to write their own filed answer with a lost minus sign, then hand it to a partner to investigate. The partner must say what is wrong and show the correct working. Then swap roles.
Make it a game
Play detectives in pairs. One player reads a filed answer aloud. The other says true or false and must prove it with working. Swap roles after each case and keep a tally of cases solved.
Mistakes to watch for
Watch forA child reads subtract negative as an ordinary subtraction and moves the wrong way on the number line.
Try thisSay the operation in words and mark it on a number line. Ask which direction a subtraction moves and what changes when the number being taken away is negative.
Watch forWith fractions that have different denominators, a child subtracts the tops and the bottoms separately, for example 2/5 subtract 1/3.
Try thisRewrite both fractions with the same denominator first. Then only the numerators are subtracted and the denominator stays.
Watch forThe working is correct but the minus sign is lost on the final line.
Try thisAsk the child to compare the answer with their estimate of the sign. If they do not match, trace back through each line to find where it vanished.
Talk about it
- How can you tell before calculating whether an answer will be positive or negative?
- Where on the number line did you start and which way did you move?
- Why do fractions need the same denominator before you add or subtract them?
- Which filed answer did you doubt first, and what made you suspicious?
- How would you explain a lost minus sign to a younger child?
- Which question was trickiest, and what helped you with it?
Take it off the page
Temperature detective
Look at a weather chart or make up temperatures above and below zero. Ask how far apart two readings are, and whether the change is a rise or a fall.
Money owed
Use pretend coins and IOU notes. Owing money is a negative amount. Practise adding more debt and having debt cancelled.
Number line on the floor
Make a long number line with masking tape and number cards. Children walk the calculations, facing the direction of travel for each one.
Who it is for
Parents
Sit with your child for the first question, then let them lead. You do not need to be fast at negative numbers yourself. Ask them to explain each step and keep page 2 for checking.
Teachers
Use it as a starter, plenary or homework after teaching operations with negative numbers, fractions and decimals. The error spotting task gives you a quick view of who really understands sign rules and who is following a half remembered rule.
Home educators
Print it as part of a wider Key Stage 3 maths plan. The explaining task works well as a spoken discussion first, then a written answer. It is easy to reuse for revision or for siblings.
Where this fits
Before this sheet, children place and order negative numbers on a number line, and add and subtract fractions with the same denominator. Year 7 work on equivalent fractions and place value in decimals is also useful groundwork.
After it, the same sign skills feed into algebra, where letters can stand for negative values, and into graphs that use all four quadrants. Confident work with fractions and decimals also supports ratio, proportion and later work with equations.
Questions parents and teachers ask
- What age is Case of the Missing Minus for?
It is written for Year 8 (ages 12 to 13), in Key Stage 3. Children in Year 7 who are confident with negative numbers can try it, and Year 9 pupils can use it for revision.
- What will children practise?
Children practise calculating with negative numbers, fractions and decimals. They also practise checking a filed answer and explaining a sign error in their own words.
- What is a filed answer?
A filed answer is an answer already written down, like a record in a case file. Children check each one against their own working and decide whether it is correct or has lost its minus sign.
- What if it feels too hard?
Offer a number line for the integer and decimal questions. For fractions, let children rewrite them with a common denominator first. Working the first question together and saying each step aloud also helps.
- Are the answers included?
Yes. Page 2 is for the grown-up and contains the answers, plus notes on using the sheet, help for children who find it hard and a stretch idea. Keep it back until the child has finished.
- Can teachers use it in class?
Yes. It works as a starter, plenary, early finisher task, homework or table activity. It needs no preparation beyond printing, and the error spotting task shows which pupils can explain their reasoning.
- Should children use a calculator?
It is best done by hand first, so the method and the sign are visible in the working. A calculator can be used afterwards to check, if you wish. Writing each line down matters most.
Preview the full PDF
Made by Jaques of London, making games for families since 1795. A printable supports classroom learning and does not replace a teacher.