Mini Minds Hub · Free printable

Always, Sometimes, Never?: Free Printable Worksheet for Year 5

  • ForYear 5
  • StageKey Stage 2
  • CostFree
  • FormatPrintable PDF

Always, Sometimes, Never? is a reasoning maths sheet for Year 5 (ages 9 to 10). Children read a claim from a suspect about factors, multiples or prime numbers, decide if it is Always, Sometimes or Never true, then prove it with examples. It suits children who can already find factors and multiples and are ready to explain why.

Before they write anything, model one claim that is not on the sheet and ask for two examples: one that fits and one that does not. The usual slip is stopping at one example that works and writing Always. Ask "Can you find one that breaks it?" each time. That single question is a quick check of understanding.

What is on the sheet

Each claim on the sheet comes from a suspect, labelled with a letter. Children read the claim, choose Always, Sometimes or Never, and then write their proof in the space provided. The claims cover factors, multiples, odd and even numbers, prime numbers, sums, products and square numbers. Children need to test numbers, spot patterns and decide whether one example is enough or whether they need more.

  • Suspect A says: Every number has 1 as a factor.
  • Suspect B says: A multiple of 10 is an even number.
  • Suspect C says: A multiple of 5 ends in the digit 5.
  • Suspect D says: A factor of a number is bigger than the number.
  • Suspect E says: A multiple of 4 is also a multiple of 2.
  • Suspect F says: A multiple of 3 is also a multiple of 6.
  • Suspect G says: A prime number is odd.
  • Suspect H says: A prime number has exactly two factors.
  • Suspect I says: A number that ends in 0 is prime.
  • Suspect J says: The sum of two prime numbers is even.
  • Suspect K says: The product of two prime numbers is prime.
  • Suspect L says: A square number has an even number of factors.

A worked example

A suspect says: A multiple of 9 is an odd number. Always, Sometimes or Never?

This claim is not one of the suspects on the sheet. It shows two ways to prove a choice.

Method 1: list and test
  1. Write the first few multiples of 9: 9, 18, 27, 36.
  2. Check each one. 9 is odd, so the claim works for 9.
  3. 18 is even, so the claim fails for 18.
  4. One example works and one fails, so the claim is true only some of the time.
Method 2: look for the reason
  1. Multiples of 9 come from 9 × 1, 9 × 2, 9 × 3 and so on.
  2. 9 × 1 = 9, which is odd. 9 × 2 = 18, which is even.
  3. The multiples switch between odd and even, so the claim cannot be Always or Never.
Sometimes. 9 is odd but 18 is even.

How to prove a claim

Test small numbers first

Pick two or three small numbers and try them. Small numbers are quick to check and often show a pattern straight away.

Look for a counterexample

A counterexample is one example that shows the claim is not true. If you find one, the claim cannot be Always.

Show both sides for Sometimes

To choose Sometimes, write one example where the claim works and one where it does not.

Give a reason for Always or Never

Examples can suggest a pattern, but a reason explains why it holds every time. Ask "Why would this keep happening?"

Why ask children to prove, not just answer?

In maths, a statement that works for a few numbers is not yet proved. Always, Sometimes, Never tasks teach children this idea in a simple form. They have to test, look for patterns and decide how much evidence is enough. The detective style gives each claim a clear job: find out whether the suspect is telling the truth.

Factors, multiples and prime numbers are a good place to practise this. The facts are familiar, but the links between them are easy to get wrong. Children who explain their choices out loud often find mistakes in their own thinking, and they hear how others reason too.

Skills and curriculum link

  • Factors and multiples
  • Prime numbers
  • Proving with examples
  • Finding counterexamples
  • Explaining reasoning

Ideas that help with proving

  • One example is not enoughAn example that fits a claim does not prove it is always true. Try some different numbers before deciding.
  • One counterexample is enoughA single example that breaks a claim shows it is not always true. Look for a counterexample as soon as a claim seems too neat.
  • Sometimes needs two examplesChoose Sometimes only when you can show one number where the claim works and one where it fails.
  • Reasons beat guessesThink about what a factor or a multiple really is. A reason built on that meaning can cover every number, not just the ones you tried.

Key words

  • ClaimA statement that might be true or might not. Each suspect makes one.
  • FactorA number that divides exactly into another number with nothing left over.
  • MultipleA number you get by multiplying a number by a whole number, like the numbers in its times table.
  • SumThe answer when you add numbers together.
  • ProductThe answer when you multiply numbers together.
  • CounterexampleOne example that shows a claim is not always true.

How to use it

  1. Print both pages. Page 1 is for your child. Keep page 2, which has notes and the answers.
  2. Read the first claim aloud. Ask your child to try it with two small numbers before they choose.
  3. Let them write Always, Sometimes or Never, then write their proof. Ask for examples, and a reason if they have one.
  4. Check against page 2. Ask "How do you know?" and talk about any choice that differs.
  5. Come back another day and try rewording the claims. Repeating a familiar activity builds confidence.

Help, stretch and game ideas

If it feels too hard

Allow a times table square. Ask your child to test each claim with two small numbers before deciding. Write the numbers down and tick or cross each one. Start with the claims that feel most familiar, then return to the harder ones.

To stretch confident children

Ask children to rewrite each Sometimes claim so that it becomes Always. They can do this by adding a condition, such as a word like odd, even or greater than 1. Then they test the new claim to check it holds.

Make it a game

Read a claim aloud. Children show thumbs up for Always, sideways for Sometimes or down for Never. Then each child defends their choice with an example. If someone finds a counterexample, the group can change their vote.

Mistakes to watch for

Watch forA child tries one example that works and writes Always.

Try thisAsk them to try a different kind of number, such as a small one, a large one or an even one. Look for one that breaks the claim.

Watch forA child mixes up factors and multiples.

Try thisSay the meaning aloud. Factors divide into a number. Multiples are in its times table. Write a short list of each for a small number.

Watch forA child writes Sometimes but gives only one example.

Try thisRemind them that Sometimes needs two examples: one where the claim works and one where it does not.

Talk about it

  • Can you find a number that proves this claim wrong?
  • How many examples do you need before you feel sure?
  • What is the difference between a factor and a multiple?
  • Is there a reason this works every time, or did you just notice a pattern?
  • Which claim was hardest to decide, and why?
  • Can you change this claim so it becomes Always?

Take it off the page

Claim cards

Write your own claims about numbers on small cards. Swap with a friend. Sort them into Always, Sometimes and Never piles and prove each one.

Times table hunt

Use a times table square. Colour the multiples of one number and look for patterns. Then colour the multiples of a second number and see where they overlap.

Factor pairs with counters

Take a small number of counters and arrange them in rows of equal length. Each arrangement shows a pair of factors. Try several different totals.

Who it is for

Parents

Sit with your child for the first claim, then let them lead. Ask for examples and reasons rather than just the choice. It is fine if they change their mind after testing another number.

Teachers

Use it after teaching factors, multiples and primes. It works as a starter, plenary or early finisher task. Pairs can compare examples and counterexamples, then share them as a class.

Home educators

Use it as a gentle reasoning task alongside your wider maths plan. Talk through each claim and let your child explain. It can be repeated later for revision or used again with brothers and sisters.

Where this fits in maths

Before this sheet, children learn their times tables, find factor pairs and sort numbers into odd and even. They also begin to describe number patterns in their own words.

After it, children use factors and multiples in more complex problems, such as finding common factors and common multiples. The habit of testing claims with examples also supports later work in algebra, where general statements are explored and proved.

Questions parents and teachers ask

What age is Always, Sometimes, Never? for?

It is written for Year 5 (ages 9 to 10), in Key Stage 2. It suits children who know their times tables and can find factors and multiples, and who are ready to explain their reasoning.

What does Sometimes mean on this sheet?

It means the claim is true for some numbers and false for others. To prove it, children give one example where the claim works and one where it does not.

What is a counterexample?

It is one example that shows a claim is not always true. If a child finds a counterexample, the claim cannot be Always, so they need to think again.

Does the sheet include answers?

Yes. Page 2 is for the grown-up and includes the answers, along with notes on how to use the sheet, help for children who find it hard and a stretch idea.

What if my child finds it too hard?

Allow a times table square. Ask them to test each claim with two small numbers before deciding. Start with the claims that feel familiar and come back to the harder ones later.

Can children work in pairs?

Yes. Pairs work well because children have to explain their examples to each other. They can then compare their examples and counterexamples with the rest of the class.

Is it free to use at home and in school?

Yes. It is free to print for home and classroom use. It prints well in black and white on plain A4 paper and needs only a pencil.

Preview the full PDF

Made by Jaques of London, making games for families since 1795. A printable supports classroom learning and does not replace a teacher.