Mini Minds Hub · Free printable

Alibis in the Overlap: Free Printable Worksheet for Year 9

  • ForYear 9
  • StageKey Stage 3
  • CostFree
  • FormatPrintable PDF

Alibis in the Overlap is a maths worksheet for Year 9 (ages 13 to 14) in which pupils use a detective case file to fill in a two set Venn tally. They then work out probabilities as fractions in their simplest form. It suits pupils who can read a Venn diagram and need practice with the overlap and the union. Page 2 gives the grown-up the answers, help ideas and a stretch task.

Model one habit first: fill in the overlap before anything else. The usual slip is counting the suspects in both circles twice. Ask pupils to add up every region of their diagram and check the total matches the number of suspects in the case file before they start on any probability.

What is on the sheet

Pupils read a case file about suspects and the places they say they visited. They fill in a table to tally how many suspects belong in each region of a two circle Venn diagram. Then they answer numbered questions about a suspect chosen at random, writing each probability as a fraction. Some questions ask them to simplify. There are multiple choice questions with three answers, and lines for writing.

  • Region of the Venn diagram
  • Number of suspects
  • How many suspects are in the harbour circle only?
  • A suspect is chosen at random. Find P(museum).
  • Find P(both places). Simplify your answer.
  • Find P(exactly one of the two places).

Worked example: a school club survey

A class of 40 pupils is surveyed. 21 play football, 17 sing in the choir and 6 do both. A pupil is chosen at random. Find P(at least one of the two activities).

This is a different case from the sheet, with different numbers. It shows two ways to reach the same answer.

Method 1: add the circles, then correct
  1. Add the two circles: 21 + 17 = 38.
  2. The 6 pupils who do both were counted twice, so take 6 away once: 38 take away 6 is 32.
  3. So 32 pupils do at least one activity. The probability is 32 out of 40, which is 32/40.
  4. Divide the top and bottom by 8 to simplify: 32/40 = 4/5.
Method 2: fill every region
  1. Overlap first: 6 do both.
  2. Football only: 21 take away 6 is 15. Choir only: 17 take away 6 is 11.
  3. At least one activity means every region inside the circles: 15 + 11 + 6 = 32.
  4. The probability is 32/40, which simplifies to 4/5.
P(at least one) = 4/5

How to build a Venn diagram from a case file

Draw two overlapping circles

Label each circle with one place or one set. Draw a box round both circles to stand for all the suspects.

Fill the overlap first

The overlap holds the suspects who belong to both sets. Write that number in before the outer parts.

Work out the outer regions

A circle total includes the overlap. Take the overlap away from each circle total to find the part that is in that circle only.

Check the whole diagram

Add every region together. The total should match the number of suspects. If it does not, look again at the overlap.

Why Venn diagrams help with probability

Venn diagrams are named after John Venn, an English logician. They use overlapping circles to show how groups share members. A person in the overlap belongs to both groups. A person outside both circles belongs to neither. Seeing the groups drawn out makes it easier to avoid counting anyone twice.

Probability connects naturally to this. When every suspect is equally likely to be picked, a probability is the number of suspects who fit, written over the total number of suspects. A Venn diagram shows the number who fit as one region or several joined together. Then the fraction is quick to write and simplify.

Skills and curriculum link

  • Venn diagrams
  • Probability as fractions
  • Overlap and union
  • Simplifying fractions
  • Reading data carefully

Ideas that help with Venn probability

  • Fractions of the wholeA probability is a part over a whole. The whole is every suspect in the case, not just those in one circle.
  • Both and eitherBoth places means the overlap. Either place means the overlap and the two outer parts of the circles joined together.
  • Counted twiceWhen two circle totals are added, anyone in both circles has been counted twice. That needs correcting once.
  • Simplest formA fraction is in its simplest form when the top and bottom share no common factor except 1. Dividing both by the same number keeps its value.

Key words

  • Venn diagramA diagram that uses overlapping circles to show how groups share members.
  • OverlapThe part where two circles meet. It holds items that belong to both sets.
  • UnionEverything in either circle or both. It is the two circles joined together.
  • ProbabilityA number that shows how likely something is. It can be written as a fraction.
  • RandomChosen so that every suspect has the same chance of being picked.
  • Simplest formA fraction with the smallest whole numbers possible, with the same value as before.

How to use it

  1. Print both pages. Page 1 is for the pupil. Keep page 2, which has the notes and answers.
  2. Read the case file together. Ask the pupil to sketch two overlapping circles and label them.
  3. Fill the table and the diagram, starting with the overlap. Check that all the regions add up to the number of suspects.
  4. Work through the probability questions in order. Write each as a fraction and simplify when asked.
  5. Check against page 2. Ask, "How did you decide which regions to use?" Come back another day to redo any tricky ones.

Help, stretch and game ideas

If it feels too hard

Offer a drawn Venn outline so pupils do not have to sketch one. Tell them to total the two circles, then subtract the people counted twice. Colour each region a different shade, and tackle the questions one at a time.

To stretch confident children

Find P(harbour given museum). This means looking only at the suspects in the museum circle. Then invent a new case with different numbers and a different overlap. Swap cases with a partner and solve each other's.

Make it a game

Pupils play detective. One reads out alibi totals for two places and the overlap. A partner builds the Venn diagram and names the overlap. Swap roles, then try to spot any case where the numbers cannot work.

Mistakes to watch for

Watch forA pupil writes the overlap in the circle total but forgets to take it away from the outer part.

Try thisRemind them a circle total includes the overlap. Write the overlap first, then work out the part that is in that circle only.

Watch forA pupil uses a circle total as the bottom of the fraction instead of the total number of suspects.

Try thisAsk, "Who could be picked?" The bottom of the fraction is every suspect in the case.

Watch forA pupil leaves a fraction unsimplified, or simplifies by changing the top and bottom differently.

Try thisCheck for a common factor. Divide the top and the bottom by the same number, so the value stays the same.

Talk about it

  • How did you decide where the overlap goes?
  • What does it mean to be in both circles?
  • Why does the bottom of every fraction stay the same?
  • What is the difference between both places and exactly one place?
  • How can you check that your diagram is right before finding any probabilities?
  • Can you think of a real life group that overlaps, like clubs or sports?

Take it off the page

Floor Venn diagram

Lay two loops of string or wool on the floor so they overlap. Sort objects like pens, coins or toys by two rules and say which go in the overlap.

Family survey

Ask family and friends two yes or no questions, like whether they like tea and whether they like coffee. Draw a Venn diagram and write the fraction in each region.

Write your own case file

Invent a short mystery with two places and a list of suspects. Make a Venn diagram for it and write three probability questions for someone else to answer.

Who it is for

Parents

Read the case file together, then let your child lead. Ask them to explain each step. If they are stuck, ask them to draw the circles and fill the overlap first. Short sessions work better than one long sitting.

Teachers

Use it as a starter, plenary, early finisher task, homework or table activity. It needs no preparation beyond printing. Page 2 has support and stretch ideas for mixed ability groups, so you can match it to your planning.

Home educators

Print it as part of a wider maths plan and use it again for brothers and sisters or for revision. It pairs well with real data, such as a family survey. Ask for method as well as answer.

Where this fits in maths

Before this sheet, pupils will have met sorting data into sets, working with fractions and simplifying them, and finding simple probabilities when every outcome is equally likely. This sheet brings those ideas together with an overlap, so pupils must think about who is counted in more than one place.

Within Key Stage 3, the same thinking leads to listing outcomes systematically using tables, grids, Venn diagrams and tree diagrams, and to probabilities of combined events. Later courses build on this with set notation and conditional probability, which the stretch idea hints at.

Questions parents and teachers ask

What age is Alibis in the Overlap for?

It is written for Year 9 (ages 13 to 14), in Key Stage 3. It suits pupils who have met Venn diagrams and simple probability before and want to practise using them together.

What will pupils practise?

Pupils practise sorting data into a two set Venn diagram and using it to find probabilities. They work with the overlap and the union, write probabilities as fractions and simplify them.

How do I use it?

Pupils may sketch two overlapping circles first. They fill the overlap before the outer regions, then work through the probabilities in order. Check the answers on page 2 afterwards and talk about the method used.

What if it feels too hard?

Offer a drawn Venn outline. Tell pupils to total the two circles, then subtract the people counted twice. Working on one question at a time, with coloured regions, can also make it feel more manageable.

Is it free?

Yes. It is free to print for home and classroom use. You can print it again for brothers, sisters or revision, and it works well in black and white on plain A4 paper.

Can teachers use it in class?

Yes. Teachers can use it as a starter, plenary, early finisher task, homework or table activity. It needs no preparation beyond printing, and page 2 has support and stretch ideas for mixed ability groups.

Is this a screen free activity?

Yes. It needs only paper and a pencil, so it works well for quiet time, rainy days and school holidays. Writing and sketching by hand also gives pupils a chance to talk through their thinking.

Preview the full PDF

Made by Jaques of London, making games for families since 1795. A printable supports classroom learning and does not replace a teacher.